IFRS vs CGNC in Morocco: Comparison and Key Differences | Upsilon Consulting

Mansour Eddekkaki

Mansour Eddekkaki

Manager — Audit & Advisory

Share
IFRS vs CGNC in Morocco: Comparison and Key Differences | Upsilon Consulting

In brief: In Morocco, the CGNC is the default accounting framework. For consolidated accounts, credit institutions apply IFRS under Bank Al-Maghrib regulations. Listed companies may use Moroccan standards or IFRS; the IFRS option is definitive. Insurers are not subject to a general IFRS adoption requirement. The differences relate to the valuation of fixed assets, the treatment of lease contracts, the accounting for financial instruments and the structure of financial statements. Understanding these gaps is essential for Moroccan groups undertaking a transition to or consolidation under international standards.

Regulatory Framework: Who Applies What?

The Moroccan accounting landscape is built on a dual framework:

The CGNC and PCGE structure general business accounting. Merchants’ accounting obligations are set by Law 9-88, promulgated by Dahir 1-92-138 of 25 December 1992, and its annexed tables.

IFRS application to consolidated accounts depends on the sector and applicable rules:

  • Listed companies may prepare consolidated accounts under Moroccan standards or IFRS. The IFRS option is definitive.
  • Credit institutions subject to Bank Al-Maghrib (BAM) directives
  • Insurance and reinsurance companies may opt for IFRS for consolidated accounts under their sector’s framework.

Statutory accounts follow the Moroccan standards applicable to the sector: CGNC for general businesses and sector-specific frameworks for regulated activities.

The same duality applies to Moroccan subsidiaries of foreign groups, which keep their statutory accounts under the CGNC and report a consolidation package under the group’s framework: these obligations are set out in our article on auditing a Moroccan subsidiary of a foreign group.

—

Overall Comparison Table

TopicCGNCIFRS
General approachAsset-based, historical costMeasurement according to the standard and asset category: cost, amortised cost or fair value
Conceptual frameworkAccounting principles under Law 9-88IASB Conceptual Framework (2018)
Financial statementsBalance sheet, CPC, ESG, TF, ETIC in the normal model; simplified model under the conditions belowStatement of financial position, comprehensive income, cash flow statement, changes in equity, notes
PrimacyLegal formEconomic substance
Revaluation of assetsExceptional (free revaluation)Permitted under the revaluation model (IAS 16)
GoodwillAmortised over estimated useful lifeNot amortised, annual impairment test (IFRS 3/IAS 36)

—

Tangible Fixed Assets: IAS 16 vs CGNC

Initial Measurement

Under the CGNC, fixed assets are recognised at acquisition cost or production cost, which forms the definitive valuation basis. IFRS (IAS 16) applies the same initial principle but adds the obligation to include estimated decommissioning and restoration costs in the asset’s cost.

Subsequent Measurement

This is where the major divergence lies:

  • CGNC: historical cost is maintained. Free revaluation is possible but rarely practised. The depreciation method reflects economic considerations and may be straight-line, declining balance or, exceptionally, progressive. New circumstances may justify revising the schedule, with reasons and effects disclosed in the ETIC.
  • IAS 16: two models to choose from — the cost model (similar to CGNC) or the revaluation model (fair value at regular intervals). The depreciation period must reflect the actual useful life and be reviewed at each closing.

Component Approach

IFRS requires a decomposition of fixed assets into components with distinct useful lives (for example: building structure 40 years, roof 20 years, technical installations 15 years). The CGNC does not explicitly provide for this component approach, although some companies adopt it voluntarily.

—

Lease Contracts: IFRS 16 vs CGNC

IFRS 16 profoundly changed the treatment of lease contracts since 2019, creating one of the most significant gaps with the CGNC.

AspectCGNCIFRS 16
ClassificationFinance lease (crédit-bail) vs operating leaseNear-elimination of the distinction for the lessee
Lessee — operating leaseLease expenses in the income statementRecognition of a right-of-use asset and a lease liability
Balance sheet impact for lesseeNone (off-balance sheet)Simultaneous increase in assets and liabilities
Income statement impactStraight-line charge (rent)Depreciation of the right-of-use asset + financial interest on the debt
IFRS 16 exemptions—Optional exemptions: leases of twelve months or less at commencement without a purchase option, and leases of assets of low value when new. IFRS 16 sets no mandatory USD 5,000 threshold

Practical impact: a listed Moroccan company that leases its offices, vehicle fleet and IT equipment will see its IFRS balance sheet significantly “heavier” than its CGNC balance sheet, with a higher debt-to-equity ratio. Financial ratios must be interpreted accordingly.

—

Financial Instruments: IFRS 9 vs CGNC

The treatment of financial instruments is another area of major divergence.

Classification and Measurement

The CGNC distinguishes, in particular, equity investments (251), other fixed securities (258), fixed debt securities (2481) and marketable securities (350). Measurement is at entry cost, with an impairment provision if current value is lower.

IFRS 9 introduces a classification into three categories based on the business model and cash flow characteristics:

  • Amortised cost: assets held to collect contractual cash flows consisting solely of principal and interest on the outstanding principal, subject to IFRS 9’s fair value through profit or loss designation option.
  • For debt instruments, fair value through OCI applies when management aims both to collect and sell, and contractual flows are solely principal and interest. A separate option exists for certain equity instruments not held for trading.
  • Fair value through profit or loss: all others, including derivatives

Impairment: Expected Losses vs Incurred Losses

The most impactful difference concerns the impairment model:

  • CGNC: an impairment provision recognises a probable loss of value at closing, based on current asset value and available information. The loss need not be definitively realised.
  • IFRS 9: expected credit loss model (ECL), which requires provisioning from the origination of the loan, even in the absence of a default event

This ECL model has a considerable impact on Moroccan banks, which must set aside provisions from the moment credit is granted, significantly increasing the cost of risk in their IFRS accounts.

—

Provisions: IAS 37 vs CGNC

Provisions for risks and charges are governed differently:

CriterionCGNCIAS 37
Recognition conditionsProbable risk, estimation possiblePresent obligation, probability of outflow of resources, reliable estimate
Provisions for major repairsPermittedProhibited — treatment through components (IAS 16)
DiscountingNot requiredMandatory if the time value effect is significant
Restructuring provisionsRisks or charges with a clearly specified purpose, made probable by past or ongoing events and estimable with sufficient approximationStrict criteria: detailed plan announced, well-founded expectation among third parties

Under IAS 37, when the time effect is significant, the provision is the discounted value of expected expenditure. With identical cash flows and a positive rate, discounting reduces the initial amount; unwinding subsequently increases it.

—

Financial Statements: Comparative Structure

The CGNC financial statements and IFRS financial statements differ in their structure and philosophy:

The normal model comprises the balance sheet, CPC, ESG, funding table and ETIC. Businesses with annual turnover not exceeding 10 million dirhams are exempt from the last three statements and may use the simplified model.

IFRS structure (5 components, IAS 1): Statement of financial position, Statement of profit or loss and other comprehensive income (OCI), Cash flow statement (IAS 7), Statement of changes in equity, Notes — with an approach oriented towards cash flows and economic performance.

The concept of comprehensive income in IFRS has no equivalent in the CGNC. It includes, beyond net income, changes in fair value of financial instruments through OCI, revaluation surpluses and translation differences.

—

Convergence Outlook in Morocco

The Conseil National de la Comptabilité (CNC) has been working for several years on a gradual alignment of the Moroccan framework with international standards. The identified convergence areas include:

  • Introduction of the component approach for fixed assets
  • Improvement of asset impairment rules
  • Modernisation of the funding table into a cash flow statement
  • Strengthening of disclosures in the notes

This convergence is progressive and takes into account the specificities of the Moroccan economic fabric, predominantly composed of SMEs for which full IFRS application would be disproportionate.

For Moroccan companies subject to both frameworks, a specialised chartered accountant is essential to manage the restatements required for the consolidation of financial statements and ensure compliance of both the CGNC statutory accounts and the IFRS consolidated accounts.

—

Legal references:

  • CGNC — Code Général de Normalisation Comptable (1992)
  • Loi 9-88 — Obligations comptables des commerçants
  • IFRS Standards: IAS 1, IAS 16, IAS 36, IAS 37, IFRS 3, IFRS 9, IFRS 16
  • AMMC Circulars — Consolidated accounts of listed companies
  • BAM Directives — Accounting framework for credit institutions

READ ALSO:


Frequently asked questions

Can a non-listed Moroccan SARL adopt IFRS?

No, the statutory accounts of Moroccan companies must be prepared in accordance with the CGNC and Law 9-88. Voluntary adoption of IFRS is not provided for by regulation for individual accounts. However, a non-listed group may choose to prepare its consolidated accounts under IFRS voluntarily, particularly to meet the requirements of international investors.

How is goodwill treated under CGNC vs IFRS?

In CGNC consolidation, positive goodwill representing an acquisition premium is recognised as an intangible asset and amortised over a reasonable period, normally no more than about ten years unless an exceptional case is justified in the ETICC. Goodwill representing a bad bargain is amortised immediately. Under IFRS (IFRS 3 / IAS 36), goodwill is never amortised but is subject to an annual impairment test. If the CGU’s recoverable amount is below its carrying amount, the loss is allocated first to goodwill and then to other assets under IAS 36. The loss allocated to goodwill cannot be reversed.

What is the impact of IFRS 16 on debt-to-equity ratios?

The application of IFRS 16 simultaneously increases assets (right-of-use) and liabilities (lease liability) on the balance sheet. The debt-to-equity ratio mechanically deteriorates, which may affect compliance with bank covenants. EBITDA improves, however, as lease charges are replaced by depreciation (excluded from EBITDA) and financial interest.

Upsilon

Consulting

An independent firm, hands-on expertise

Upsilon Consulting is a chartered accounting, audit and tax advisory firm, statutory auditor registered with the Moroccan Institute of Chartered Accountants. Our team of 40 professionals has been supporting Moroccan and multinational companies since 2011. Our multidisciplinary approach and client proximity allow us to support you with rigour and responsiveness.

OEC Members Technical expertise Multidisciplinary approach Client proximity

Let's talk about your project

For a question about your situation, write to us. Our experts respond within 24h.

Newsletter

Stay ahead of tax & regulatory changes

Get our expert analyses, practical guides and regulatory alerts delivered to your inbox. Join 500+ professionals who trust us.

No spam. Unsubscribe in one click.

They trust us

PfizerAlstomDrägerCFAO MotorsCDG CapitalBourse de Casablanca